Substitute For Cremini Mushrooms

Cremini mushrooms are the most popular varieties you will find at the supermarket. Cremini mushrooms are loved for their firm texture and rich flavor. You can use them in many dishes, including pasta sauces and risottos. Cremini mushrooms are the same mushroom as Portobello and white button mushrooms.

In terms of their age, they’re between the two types. Sometimes, cremini mushrooms can be called baby portobello mushrooms or baby Bella mushrooms. Cremini mushrooms have an earthy and aromatic smell when they grow from the soil. Vegetarians and vegans can use its fleshy texture as a substitute for meat.

Cremini Mushrooms

Alternatives and Substitutes For Cremini Mushrooms

Cremini mushrooms can be used in various recipes, including soups, sauces, barbecues, and burgers. However, not everyone can eat them in their meals. You may not like its taste or have insufficient for the recipe you are trying to make. Here are some substitutions for these fungi, but if you are looking for normal mushroom alternatives then we have them covered as well for you to make tasty recipes.

White Button Mushrooms

The first item on our list is White Button Mushrooms. These are also referred to as champignons or common mushrooms found in your local supermarket. White Button Mushrooms tend to be white, and the thing that makes them unique is their delicate, mild flavor and extremely fine texture. They are part of the same genus of mushrooms typically found in all homes and are delicious to eat.

Additionally, they’re identical in size to cremini mushrooms. If you compare the two types, there is a resemblance and the features which make them an excellent alternative to each other. If your recipe calls for cremini mushrooms, you could use white button mushrooms. They’re perfect for salads, sauces to dip, or adding a little flavor to your food. 

The white button mushroom is softer in taste than cremini since they are younger. When cooked with the right ingredients, spice and seasonings, they are as good as cremini mushrooms. They are sometimes called Table mushrooms or cultivated mushrooms, grocery mushrooms, commonly mushrooms, or champignon.

Additionally, they are readily available throughout the year at all supermarkets worldwide. Cremini and white button mushrooms are similar in size, shape and taste. However, the latter are either a dazzling bright white color or an off-white one and a smooth texture and an enticing taste.

White Button Mushrooms

Portobello Mushrooms

Portobello mushrooms are more mature, larger baby Bellas. Therefore, they are huge, luxurious and delicate. They share a smooth, mushroom-like taste and flavor similar to cremini mushrooms. Portobello has an umami-like taste, making it a great alternative to meat, similar to cremini. They are a good alternative to cremini mushrooms because they are bigger and fully grown.

Portobello mushroom has a supple texture and a meaty taste. They are great to grill, roast or do baking. They also work perfectly with pasta sauces and barbecues. Portobellos contain high water levels and can lose their shape when cooked, but their flavor will not change.

They are typically used in filled mushroom dishes; however, they can also substitute cremini mushrooms in other recipes. They also can hold an abundance of moisture. Therefore, if you’re making pizza sauce, marinara sauce toppings or pasta, easily add chopped or sliced portobello mushrooms into those recipes.

They are cheap and are readily available at the local supermarkets. Portobello is often referred to as the giant cremini mushroom. In keeping with this nickname, it is the closest alternative to cremini due to its taste, appearance and earthy scent. 


Maitake mushrooms

Maitake mushrooms are a tasty, healthy food item to include in your daily diet! You can use them in cremini mushrooms in cooking because they are similar in taste and feel. This superfood grows in the forest of Japan, and it is also a millennia-old favorite. It is enriched with polysaccharides and beta-glucans up to D1 and D2; these components boost immunity. They also regulate blood sugar levels and metabolism. 

Among the varieties of mushrooms, Maitakes are the only ones with less fat than the others. This makes them the ideal meat-free option when working towards that resolution for the New Year.  Additionally, the high vitamins and minerals found in these delicious fungi supply you with strength and energy.

Maitake mushrooms are found in Japan However; they aren’t readily accessible. They are less fat choices for mushrooms, making them the meatless option. Maitake mushrooms have the exact flavor and texture as cremini mushrooms.


Shiitake mushrooms

Shiitake mushrooms are very popular in Asian cuisine. They can also be found under black forests, and Chinese mushrooms can be used as a substitute for cremini mushrooms. These mushrooms are soft and brown, but they have a more meaty texture than cremini mushrooms.

Some people may not like the texture of shiitake mushrooms, so make sure to substitute. They are great for pasta, sauces, stews, risotto, and barbecue because they add a rich flavor. You will not regret buying them.

Shiitake mushrooms are Chinese black mushrooms, Forest mushrooms, Black Forest mushrooms, Golden Oak mushrooms, Oak mushrooms, and oriental black mushrooms. In shape and size, they are very similar to cremini mushrooms.

They can also be used as a substitute for cremini mushrooms. They are healthier than dried shiitake mushrooms. They are rich in fibers, minerals, and other vitamins. They can be used to make soups, curries, risottos, soups, and marinara sauces. 

They are more common in Asia, Shiitake mushrooms are often available nearby grocery stores. Shiitake mushrooms are similar in size and shape to cremini mushrooms. However, fresh Shiitakes have more nutrients than dried. Although this type of mushroom is more popular in Asia, it can be found anywhere.

The shiitake mushrooms are rich in flavor. However, to get the best taste, they must be fresh. Dry shiitake mushrooms will not taste as good compared to Cremini Mushrooms. 

Shiitake Mushrooms

Oyster Mushrooms

There is no better way to experiment with oyster mushrooms than cremini mushrooms. Oyster mushrooms are sweeter and have strong umami undertones. They are great with many savory dishes, and they have a wide range of flavors. These mushrooms do have some downsides.

They are larger than normal, making them more noticeable in many dishes. Some people may find their soft exterior a deceptive sign. These mushrooms are noticeably more delicate than cremini and have a light, fishy flavor.

While we recommend being cautious when substituting oyster mushrooms for other ingredients, it is worth the effort if you have the right recipe. You must note that this mushroom has a weaker flavor than other alternatives on our list.

These mushrooms are costly and can only be purchased in dried form. It is easy to rehydrate these mushrooms and retain their flavor well. Some people don’t like the texture of this mushroom in soups or casseroles.

Because of their distinctive branching shape, oyster mushrooms can be easily identified in supermarkets. Oyster mushrooms are also known for their unique stringy texture, making them an excellent vegetarian alternative to pulled pork.

Oyster mushrooms are similar to cremini mushrooms in flavor, making them a perfect substitute for sauces and side dishes. Oyster mushrooms are slightly sweeter than cremini mushrooms, but this can only enhance certain dishes’ flavor. 

King Oyster mushrooms are large and meaty and can also be used to substitute for meat. Some people may be allergic to spores as this can cause stomach ache. They have many health benefits, including being rich in copper and vitamins (vitamins D3, B2, B3, and B5) that help maintain brain, blood sugar, and skin health. They are great in soups, stews, and sauces, as well as in stir-fry or sauteed.

Oyster Mushrooms

Morel Mushrooms

Because of their similar flavor, morel mushrooms are included on this list. These mushrooms are rich in umami flavors and maybe the most beneficial of all mushrooms. Morel mushrooms have a similar texture to other meats and can be paired with any protein.

They can be used in many different ways and have a unique nutty taste. To make them more like cremini mushrooms, we recommend adding some herbs.

Cremini mushrooms have a lower nutritional profile than morels, but they are more susceptible to spices and high heat. They are more likely to lose their flavor and aroma while being cooked, so it is best to cook them separately. 

Look no further if you are looking for a mushroom to add some extra flavor to your dishes. These fungi look, feel, and smell very similar to cremini mushrooms. Morel mushrooms are milder in flavor than shiitake mushrooms, which makes them ideal for people who don’t want strong-flavored mushrooms such as shiitake. These mushrooms also don’t require rehydration before being cooked and are much cheaper than oyster mushrooms.

This mushroom has one major drawback: it can be hard to find in the grocery store. You might be able to spot them in the produce section or at a local farmer’s market if you are lucky. Most people order morel mushrooms online.

Morel Mushrooms

Enoki mushrooms

Enoki mushrooms are mildly sweet-tasting mushrooms that can be used to satisfy your cravings and fill any void. Because of its high level of fiber and protein, it can help maintain a healthy heart. These edible mushrooms are from the genus Foeniculum. Because of their small size and earthy flavor, they are often used in Japanese cuisine. Enoki mushrooms are an excellent substitute for cremini mushrooms. They have three calories per portion. 

Enoki also has nutritional value, with nine B vitamins and minerals like potassium and phosphorus, including our favorite superpower, Vitamin D. Comparing enoki’s low water content to other vegetables such as tomatoes and green peppers, you will see that enoki has a higher level of vitamin C.

Enoki mushrooms

Porcini Mushroom

Porcini mushrooms are another great substitute for cremini mushrooms. Porcini mushrooms come in various colors, including dark brown and tan. They are known for their strong flavor and aroma, and they should only be used fresh. Porcini mushrooms are a great choice if you’re looking for a mushroom with a strong flavor and delicate aroma.

These mushrooms are a perfect size, so they don’t show up in your dish. Similar nutrient levels to cremini mushrooms, they are porous, making them more water-absorbent. When cooking, rinse them well and dry them with paper towels to get the best results. They release water during cooking which can make your dish moisture.

Porcini Mushroom


In different parts of the globe, eggplant is known as brinjal in various countries. If you don’t like mushrooms or are allergic to them, eggplant may be healthier. Eggplants have low carbohydrate content, and Eggplants are high in fiber and delicious.

You can use them to make sauces, stews, and curries. The best part about eggplant is that it can be made vegan, making it ideal for those who eat a plant-based diet. In some regions, also known as Garden egg or guinea squash, melongene, or brinjal. 

The eggplant can replace cremini and other types of fungus. Eggplant, which has a meaty flavor similar to creminis, is a smart choice of alternative for vegans. This purple plant is widespread in markets. The purple and oval eggplant is a nightshade vegetable.

Both have an earthy flavor, but eggplant is slightly bitterer. If you’re making a dish that doesn’t include mushrooms, you can substitute cremini mushrooms for eggplant in risottos, stews, and pasta sauces. You may need to salt eggplant before you cook it. However, eggplant is bitter than mushrooms. This can make a significant difference in the flavor and texture of your recipe.

eggplant image

Frequently Asked Questions about cremini mushrooms

Can you eat cremini mushrooms’ gills?

The stems of Cremini are tender and delicious. Just trim the ends. Portobello gills can be eaten, but they will give your dish a darker brown color. You can avoid this by scraping the gills with a teaspoon. You can keep mushrooms fresher longer by taking them out of their containers.

How long can Cremini mushrooms last?

Cremini mushrooms can be refrigerated for as long as four days, and up to seven days, without experiencing any quality changes.

Can you eat raw cremini mushrooms?

Cremini mushrooms can be used in many ways. You can slice them and eat them raw, but most people prefer to prepare them. some people also like to pair them grilled and mixed with right sauces and spices along with different recipes like candied yams, mashed potatoes, chicken salads, casseroles etc to make a flavorful meal to enjoy with family and friends.

Rate this post

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *